Volunteer/Employee Background Check Policy and Procedures
Organizations know background checks help reduce risk, maintain a safe environment and minimize liability. Yet it can be a challenging topic of discussion and often brings up questions such as when, how often, for whom, how important is it really, and what happens if we don’t do background checks. This article will address some of those questions and provide some general guidelines and information to get the conversation started.
Start by Creating a Policy
The first step, prior to implementing background checks, is to develop a higher level framework and policy for background checks. This should fit into your overall child protection policy and procedures. Determine who will have background checks, when, how often, what information to obtain from your volunteers/employees, who will review the results of the background check and how you’ll handle any concerns.
Once you’ve determined your plan, commit as a team and full staff to always follow these policies and procedures – stand firm, no exceptions. This provides a consistent process should any possible legal issues arise. It also allows you to confidently assure parents that everyone working with children in your organization has committed to your child protection policy and has undergone a background check.
Consistency is Key
Make a policy and commit to stick to that policy. Once you have a background check system in place, do not deviate from your background check standards. Any deviation can open you up to be liable for an incident and/or a negligence law suit. That means even those you (or your leadership team) know and trust must go through the same background check policy. Consider the serious consequences if you don’t complete a background check on someone because you thought they were a good fit and something goes wrong.
We can’t stress enough – do not allow for deviations from your policies and procedures. Should you ever find yourself in front of a judge or in a law suit, you need to have that consistent policy in place and prove you did everything you could to prevent the situation from occurring.
Volunteer/Employee Rights to Know
American citizens and employers are within their rights to run a background check on any individual. Per the Consumer Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), “a background check for volunteers may be covered by the FCRA as well. To fall under the FCRA, a volunteer background check must be conducted by a third-party screening company.” The FCRA reports on an individual’s “credit worthiness, credit standing, credit capacity, character, general reputation, personal characteristics, or mode of living”.
When you have a third party provide information about an individual you must have written consent from the individual in order to complete a background check. This includes your volunteers. If in fact any information is uncovered in the background check that prevents the individual from being a part of your childcare program, should they ask, you must share that information with them. Anyone undergoing a background investigation has the right to know what is in their file that may affect them.
Third Party Review
Once a background check is completed, based on the results, you still have the choice whether or not to approve that person. Your policy should include having an unbiased third party examine the information and make a determination on anyone still in question. Leaving this to a professional, such as an attorney, helps keep you and your staff from negligence or any personal liability for a misjudgment. Using a third party professional incorporates a level of checks and balances in your system.
As utilizing a third party is not always a viable option, consider setting up a council made up of just a few trusted members in your organization to review background check results and decide on eligibility. Including someone with law or law enforcement experience would be beneficial. It is not advised to have just one individual in the organization completing the review as there could be bias or a possible increase in liability. However, if using a group, the total number should remain small as confidentiality and privacy elements are associated. When creating your policies and procedures, make sure your employee or volunteer understands this information will be shared with the review board.
In addition to obtaining consent to complete the initial background check, your policy should include a signed written agreement by the volunteer/employee noting their willingness to participate in future background checks; and that they will notify you of any criminal arrest or offense that occurs after they are hired. Include this signed agreement when you run your ongoing or annual background checks. This will help protect you by consistently monitoring their status long term. Some services will provide a constant monitoring system and update you automatically if there are changes to a volunteer or employee’s records. Completing background checks every year is recommended.
In addition to policies and procedures, you also need a solid, secure system to keep this information private so that you are not in breach of privacy. Keep all background check applications and result information in a controlled secure environment that is locked or password protected. This information should only be available for the authorized individuals or review board. In some cases you may upload this information into a secure encrypted cloud based system or you may keep files on hand. Either way follow the Privacy Rights Clearinghouse guideline that “personal information should be protected by reasonable security safeguards against such risks as loss, unauthorized access, destruction, use, modification or disclosure.”
Background Check Providers
When choosing a background check provider keep in mind you want one that utilizes a true national criminal database search, and a state by state sex offender search. The National Child Protection Act (NCPA) of 1993 opened access to the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s (FBI) national criminal records files to schools, day care facilities and youth-serving organizations. This opened a potentially new avenue for screening out child molesters or other conduct that might pose a risk to the organization. However, access to the FBI’s files under the NCPA was contingent on a state law that granted access and by 1998 only six states had laws on the books allowing nonprofit organizations access to the FBI files. With so few states involved this is why the ability to search a true national criminal database search is so important.
Integrated background checks through KidCheck with our partner Protect My Ministry provide fast, easy and thorough background checks from a highly credible provider. The background checks include SSN Verification and Address History, National Criminal Database Search, National Sex Offender Search, Re-verification of Criminal Records and Alias Names. Also available is an option to include a County or Statewide Criminal Court Search.
To learn more about KidCheck’s feature rich, secure child check-in system, visit the KidCheck website or join us on Twitter, Facebook, Google+, or Pinterest.
#kidmin #fammin #youthmin #checkin #churchsafety #church #pastor #ministry
Additional Resources Link:
Volunteer/Childcare Worker Application
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse Volunteer Background Checks
Fair Credit Reporting Act
National Child Protection Act
04/08/2019 at 4:51 am
I have a question about the recommended worker application. We used it the first year with KidCheck, thank you. Our Children’s Ministry policy states to complete the application each year. I don’t see that suggested on the KidCheck web site. We are coming up on the new school year and I’m wondering if KidCheck recommends completing an application each year. If it is a good practice to complete an application annually (i.e., legal), then of course we need to. Over half the information on the form is contact or background information that should not change each year. The “have you ever” questions seem unnecessary if the background checks are effective (we use Protect My Ministry). Our former Director of Children’s Ministry is no longer in contact with us and our former intentional interim pastor is undergoing cancer treatments.
Thank you for KidCheck and your great support team.
04/08/2019 at 10:45 am
Hi Andy, Thanks for checking in about background checks. So great you are making child safety a priority! We do recommend the background check be completed every 12-24 months depending on the person’s role and if they are working directly with children. Here is a blog series that provides details on the 7 steps needed for comprehensive screening and one of the steps is specific to background checks. We hope this information is helpful to you. Also, if you’d like to further discuss, call or email and you can talk with our child protection specialist.